Implied malice in California homicide cases occurs when someone acts with a conscious disregard for human life, knowing their actions are dangerous but proceeding anyway. This concept often arises in second-degree murder cases, where there is no direct intent to kill, but the person’s reckless behavior shows an indifference to the risk of death.
Implied malice distinguishes second-degree murder from manslaughter by focusing on the defendant’s awareness of the danger their actions posed. For example, driving under the influence at extreme speeds and causing a fatal crash may demonstrate implied malice under California law.
If you are facing charges involving implied malice, a Los Angeles homicide and murder defense lawyer can help you understand the legal implications and build a strong defense. Consulting an experienced attorney ensures you have the support you need to navigate these serious charges effectively.
What Is Malice?
To qualify as murder rather than manslaughter, there must be evidence of “malice aforethought” before the act. Legally, malice refers to the intent to commit an unlawful act without justification or excuse. If malice is present, it becomes difficult to argue that the act was unintentional or necessary.
Prosecutors may try to demonstrate malice aforethought by portraying you as cruel, reckless, or indifferent to the consequences of your actions. This characterization is often used to secure the most severe charges and penalties, even when they may not be warranted by the circumstances.
If you are facing accusations of malice or elevated charges, a Los Angeles violent crimes lawyer can advocate for you. They can challenge the prosecution’s portrayal, negotiate for reduced charges, and work toward getting the charges dropped entirely if possible. Having an experienced attorney by your side is critical when dealing with serious accusations like these.
For a free legal consultation, call (310) 896-2723
How Is Malice Applied to Homicide Cases?
In homicide cases, malice is the critical element that separates murder from manslaughter. Manslaughter generally involves unintentional killings, such as those resulting from car accidents, where harm was not intended. It may also apply to actions taken impulsively or with reckless disregard for safety but without malice.
Murder requires proof of malice, which can be either expressed (a clear intent to kill) or implied (reckless actions showing disregard for human life). When malice is established, the offense is categorized as murder, carrying significantly harsher penalties than manslaughter.
If you are facing accusations involving malice, a Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer can assess the circumstances of your case and provide a strong defense. By challenging the prosecution’s evidence and interpretation of events, an attorney can work toward a favorable resolution of your case.
What Is Implied Malice?
According to the California Penal Code (CPC) §188, there are two types of malice: express and implied. Express malice is easier to spot, and if it’s present, the murder case is clearly defined. Express malice is any type of malice that is outwardly expressed, usually through a verbal threat, a note, or any other type of expression of intent to kill.
Implied malice, however, is more complicated. Implied malice, as defined by the CPC, happens “when no considerable provocation appears, or when the circumstances attending the killing show an abandoned and malignant heart.”
In general, it’s considered implied malice when someone acts in such a way that they know their actions can kill someone and they don’t do anything to mitigate that. This is different than unintentionally hurting someone–instead, it’s a disregard for any other person’s life.
Examples of Implied Malice
Examples of express malice are fairly clear-cut–a note, a threat, or a confession can all count as outward signs of malice. However, implied malice is sometimes harder to spot, and cases of implied malice can be more nuanced.
One common example of implied malice is drunk driving. Usually, death due to drunk driving is considered vehicular manslaughter because of the accidental nature of most DUI crashes. However, in some cases, drunk drivers could be charged with murder due to implied malice.
This is because of the California Supreme Court’s ruling in People v Watson (1981), where defendant Watson crashed, killing two people. Watson’s blood alcohol content (BAC) was almost three times higher than the legal limit, and they were speeding by a significant amount. The California Supreme Court decided that the defendant exhibited implied malice and was guilty of second-degree murder.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Common Defenses for Implied Malice
Because implied malice is a complicated thing to prove, there are some defenses that homicide defense attorneys in L.A. often use to keep their clients from getting an elevated charge. Common defenses against the implied malice rule include that:
- The defendant was acting in self-defense
- The defendant was acting recklessly, but with no malice
- The defendant was not in their right mind at the time
It’s incredibly difficult for a defendant to prove one of these defenses by themself. That’s why you should have a skilled criminal defense lawyer by your side to help get you through your trial. With our help, you could have your charges reduced to manslaughter or even dropped entirely.
For more information about your homicide case, you can always get a free consultation with one of our defense attorneys. They will assess your situation and tell you what the next steps should be in your defense.
Talk to a Homicide Lawyer in California for Free
If you’re facing a homicide charge, the prosecutor may try to elevate it from manslaughter to murder using the implied malice rule. They shouldn’t be able to get away with charging you with something you’re not guilty of.
California homicide lawyers from Simmrin Law Group can help. We have years of experience helping people with criminal charges, and we know how to deal with tricky prosecutors. With our help, you can keep your charge at a reasonable level.
We offer free consultations, so there’s no risk in at least talking to us about your situation. Call us or contact us online to get started.
Call or text (310) 896-2723 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form