“Dismissed with prejudice” means a case is permanently closed and cannot be refiled or brought before the court again. The court has decided to end the case and bar any future attempts to bring the charges back to court.
When a case is dismissed with prejudice, it is usually due to insufficient evidence, procedural errors, or other issues that render it unfair to the defendant. In a California civil or criminal case, either party can file a motion to dismiss, which will terminate the case.
A Los Angeles criminal defense lawyer can help you understand complicated legal terms related to your case. If you’re still wondering, “What does dismissed with prejudice mean?”, contact our team today to get a free consultation.
What Is “Dismissed Without Prejudice”?
While charges dismissed with prejudice may not be tried again, “dismissal without prejudice” means the prosecutor can refile the case within a specific time frame. In California, there are three reasons a case can be dismissed without prejudice:
- Lack of jurisdiction: This means the crime occurred outside the court’s jurisdiction, and they cannot handle your criminal charges.
- Improper service of process: This is when the court did not notify you of the proceedings properly.
- Improper venue: In this situation, a judge determines that another court should handle the case.
These procedural issues do not reflect your case’s substantive issues. A criminal defense lawyer can explain “dismissed without prejudice” and what it means for your case.
For a free legal consultation, call (310) 896-2723
What Are Valid Reasons for Dismissal With Prejudice?
The main reason you will see a dismissal with prejudice is that there was a violation of your constitutional rights. This might include prosecutorial misconduct, procedural errors, or serious issues within the legal system or justice system.
For example, there was an arrest without probable cause, which is a violation under criminal law. The prosecution cannot go back to the time of the arrest and make up a reason, and therefore, the result is a dismissal with prejudice.
This legal term often serves as an adjudication on the merits, preventing further legal proceedings under res judicata.
What Is Double Jeopardy?
The Constitution prohibits double jeopardy, meaning no person can be tried twice for the same criminal case or criminal charges. A dismissal with prejudice can occur if the court empaneled a jury, the first witness was sworn in, and the court acquitted the defendant during a jury trial.
However, one court can convict you of a crime, and a higher court, like the Supreme Court or District Courts, can overturn the decision and retry the defendant; this is not considered double jeopardy under the Fifth Amendment.
What Is the Role of Prejudice in the Legal Justice System?
Essentially, prejudice in the court system makes the decision final, meaning the case dismissed cannot be refiled or retried in future court orders.
Once a court forms a decision with prejudice, it is binding under civil law and the doctrine of res judicata, ensuring protection of constitutional rights and preventing additional motions to dismiss filings for the same issue.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Does “Dismissed With Prejudice” Mean Your Legal Trouble Is Over?
What does “dismissed with prejudice” signify concerning your legal issues? Cases dismissed with prejudice mean your legal troubles regarding this specific criminal charge will be over, as it acts as a final adjudication on the merits.
However, if it is dismissed without prejudice or a dismissal without prejudice, the state can take legal action against you again under the statute of limitations.
A criminal defense attorney at Simmrin Law Group can help you face voluntary dismissals, involuntary dismissals, and ensure your constitutional rights are protected throughout the California criminal court system.
What Is Voluntary Dismissal?
The prosecutor, the party that files the criminal case, can voluntarily dismiss it when they determine there is insufficient cause for moving forward. The judge will decide whether it is a dismissal with prejudice or a dismissal without prejudice based on the facts.
The plaintiff or prosecutor will have no say in the judge’s decision, even though they moved to dismiss, as this falls under the authority of the legal system and its procedural rules.
What Is an Involuntary Dismissal?
An involuntary dismissal happens when there is something inherently wrong with the prosecution’s case, such as prosecutorial misconduct, procedural errors, or failure to comply with court orders. The judge will decide whether it is dismissed with prejudice or dismissed without prejudice.
When they dismiss without prejudice, it gives the prosecution more time to prepare a valid argument and retry the case before the statute of limitations expires. While the prosecutor will have more time to prepare, so will your criminal defense lawyer in California.
The judge can also decide to dismiss with prejudice when the prosecution continues to request delays or fails to address issues, ensuring fairness and due process within the legal proceedings.
Is There a Delay to the Statute of Limitations?
There are many statutes of limitations for legal matters, and when a case is dismissed without prejudice, the deadline does not increase. However, the prosecution will still need to refile before the original statute of limitations for the specific offenses.
If the prosecution delays refiling, the case will automatically be dismissed with prejudice, and you will be free from legal troubles.
What Is the Dismissal Process?
Usually, your criminal defense lawyer will file a motion to initiate the dismissal process, and the other side will have the opportunity to respond to the motion.
There are two ways to file for dismissal:
- When the plaintiff files a motion for voluntary dismissal
- When the defense lawyer files a motion for involuntary dismissal
How Long Can a Case Be Dismissed Without Prejudice?
The answer to this question depends on your situation, since a dismissal without prejudice will be contingent on the charges you are facing. Every criminal charge in California has a different statute of limitations.
For example, if your case is dismissed within a year of the statute, and the statute is two years, there will be one year left when the prosecution refiles against you.
What Should I Do if My Case Was Dismissed Without Prejudice?
A dismissal without prejudice is scary because you must go through the court process again. Consult with your criminal defense lawyer to determine how much time is left in the statute of limitations and what the prosecution will likely do.
Even though they represent you, they may not get notice of a refiling, so when you receive the notice, ensure you call your California criminal defense lawyer immediately.
Criminal Defense Lawyers in California Can Help
So, what does dismissed with prejudice mean? It means you will walk away and move on with your life. However, “dismissal without prejudice” means the case is put on hold for now, and there will be a refiling.
You need a California criminal defense lawyer who can prepare for either dismissal action. The goal is to receive a dismissal with prejudice, as that is what will give you your life back. However, we will also prepare for the alternative.
Simmrin Law Group has been defending clients for decades. Attorney Michael Simmrin has tried over 100 jury trials, and he knows the law. Contact us today to find out how we can help.
Call or text (310) 896-2723 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form